- Видео 348
- Просмотров 30 757 524
Rowan J Coleman
Великобритания
Добавлен 2 июл 2011
The home of Rowan J Coleman's in depth Retrospective/Reviews on science fiction and superhero TV shows and movies. Chronicling the behind the scenes of each show and movie as well as their lasting pop culture impact. Check out playlists for the 18 part Star Trek Retrospective, 2 part Babylon 5 Retrospective and keep an eye on the community tab for upcoming Retrospective announcements.
BECOME A CHANNEL MEMBER
ruclips.net/channel/UCPuIelJAFD65XeuafQAu-tAjoin
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
www.patreon.com/rowanjcoleman
JOIN THE DISCORD SERVER
discord.gg/BYxQNuD
All copyrighted material falls under fair use for the purpose of analysis, discussion and review.
BECOME A CHANNEL MEMBER
ruclips.net/channel/UCPuIelJAFD65XeuafQAu-tAjoin
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
www.patreon.com/rowanjcoleman
JOIN THE DISCORD SERVER
discord.gg/BYxQNuD
All copyrighted material falls under fair use for the purpose of analysis, discussion and review.
Stargate Atlantis (2004) Retrospective/Review - Stargate Retrospective, Part 4
Head to squarespace.com/rowanjcoleman to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using code rowanjcoleman
In 1994, the sci-fi adventure film, Stargate became a surprise blockbuster hit, but the mythos didn’t secure a lasting legacy until it moved to television in the form of Stargate SG1. It was so successful that during its sixth year, talks began regarding a new television spin-off in the form of Stargate Atlantis.
Patreon: www.patreon.com/rowanjcoleman
Discord: discord.gg/BYxQNuD
Special thanks to all Patrons and Members!
00:00 Squarespace Ad
00:56 Intro
01:42 Development
04:16 Casting
08:10 Production
11:51 Rising
17:33 Season 1
19:59 The Genii
20:56 The Storm & The Eye/John Sheppa...
In 1994, the sci-fi adventure film, Stargate became a surprise blockbuster hit, but the mythos didn’t secure a lasting legacy until it moved to television in the form of Stargate SG1. It was so successful that during its sixth year, talks began regarding a new television spin-off in the form of Stargate Atlantis.
Patreon: www.patreon.com/rowanjcoleman
Discord: discord.gg/BYxQNuD
Special thanks to all Patrons and Members!
00:00 Squarespace Ad
00:56 Intro
01:42 Development
04:16 Casting
08:10 Production
11:51 Rising
17:33 Season 1
19:59 The Genii
20:56 The Storm & The Eye/John Sheppa...
Просмотров: 49 199
Видео
E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial (1982) Retrospective/Review
Просмотров 15 тыс.21 день назад
Head to squarespace.com/rowanjcoleman to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using code rowanjcoleman In 1977, director Steven Spielberg wowed audiences with the spectacular science fiction adventure Close Encounters of the Third Kind. After a costly flop with his comedy, 1941, Spielberg returned to form with Raiders of the Lost Ark. Once again an in-demand director, Spielbe...
Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977) Retrospective/Review
Просмотров 51 тыс.Месяц назад
In 1977, in the wake of Star Wars, audiences were given another dose of the sci-fi fantastical in Close Encounters of the Third Kind. Audiences were no strangers to aliens and flying saucers in movies, but that kind of subject matter was usually in the domain of cheap B-movies from a bygone era. At the tail end of such a cynical decade of cinema, it must have been utterly dazzling to be met wit...
Stargate SG1 (Seasons 6-10) Retrospective/Review - Stargate Retrospective, Part 3
Просмотров 79 тыс.2 месяца назад
Stargate SG1 rode success for five years, garnering a passionate fanbase who now saw the series as the definitive incarnation of Stargate, superseding the original movie. It was quite a shock to these fans when at the end of its fifth season, the show was cancelled by its original network and one of its main cast members departed the series. If any other series was dealt such a blow, it likely ...
Star Trek's "Cinematic" Problem
Просмотров 124 тыс.2 месяца назад
For the longest time, Star Trek existed as a low-budget TV show. Next to sci-fi blockbusters like Star Wars, Star Trek always seemed cheaper and dare we say, kinda lame. But all of that changed in 2009. Director JJ Abrams completely overhauled Star Trek’s visual style for his reboot of the mythos. Though Abrams is no longer involved in the Star Trek mythos, modern Star Trek generally took his s...
Stargate SG1 (Seasons 1-5) Retrospective/Review - Stargate Retrospective, Part 2
Просмотров 124 тыс.3 месяца назад
In 1994 science fiction was gifted a new icon in the form of Stargate. Though it received mixed reviews from critics, the film wowed audiences with its imaginative concepts, impressive effects and spectacular world. The film became the sleeper hit of that year and it didn’t take long for the film’s director Roland Emmerich and producer Dean Devlin to start entertaining the idea of a sequel. Alt...
What Good Writing Actually Means
Просмотров 12 тыс.3 месяца назад
In any online discussion surrounding film, TV, novels, comics, games - stories in general - one of the most common criticisms thrown around is “bad writing.” This is a term I’ve grown to really dislike. Not only is this term incredibly vague but it also splits the craft of storytelling into a reductive binary. There is bad writing and then there is good writing. Which begs the question, what do...
Should We Fear Technology? - The Philosophy of Star Trek
Просмотров 21 тыс.4 месяца назад
Have you ever noticed how weirdly rustic Star Trek's future looks? Despite the presence of highly advanced physics-defying technologies, there's a conspicuous absence of automation and cybernetics as well as the lack of advanced robotics. Elements which are common to other sci-fi universes are all missing from Star Trek. Why? Patreon: www.patreon.com/rowanjcoleman Discord: discord.gg/BYxQNuD Sp...
How Star Trek's Future Works - Money, Work and Property
Просмотров 207 тыс.4 месяца назад
How does Star Trek’s future society work? A world without money seems alien to the point of impossibility to many people. The difficulty in answering this question has led to numerous fan theories, essays, non-fiction books and even some dismissals. So here is my two cents on the subject. It’s based on what we’ve seen and heard in the Star Trek mythos combined with my extrapolations and ideas t...
Stargate (1994) Retrospective/Review - Stargate Retrospective, Part 1
Просмотров 115 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Stargate Retrospective, Part 1: In the early 90s, fresh off the success of Universal Soldier, director Roland Emmerich and producer Dean Devlin, sought to make a new sci-fi epic adventure which would merge the ancient and the alien. The result was the 1994 movie, Stargate! Though never lauded as a work of great storytelling, Stargate's rich mythos and striking visuals would soon spawn a vast un...
Utopia is Not the End - The Philosophy of Star Trek #2
Просмотров 61 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Utopia is Not the End - The Philosophy of Star Trek #2
Farscape (1999) Retrospective/Review
Просмотров 230 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Farscape (1999) Retrospective/Review
Is Humanity Good? - The Philosophy of Star Trek #1
Просмотров 53 тыс.7 месяцев назад
Is Humanity Good? - The Philosophy of Star Trek #1
Backstory is NOT Personality - Why Avatar's Characters Are Good Actually [REUPLOAD]
Просмотров 7 тыс.7 месяцев назад
Backstory is NOT Personality - Why Avatar's Characters Are Good Actually [REUPLOAD]
Hypercompetent Characters Are Great, Actually
Просмотров 25 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Hypercompetent Characters Are Great, Actually
The Real Heroes of Battlestar Galactica
Просмотров 37 тыс.8 месяцев назад
The Real Heroes of Battlestar Galactica
Children of Dune (2003) Retrospective/Review - Dune Retrospective, Part 3
Просмотров 43 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Children of Dune (2003) Retrospective/Review - Dune Retrospective, Part 3
Dune Miniseries (2000) Retrospective/Review - Dune Retrospective, Part 2
Просмотров 59 тыс.9 месяцев назад
Dune Miniseries (2000) Retrospective/Review - Dune Retrospective, Part 2
How to Build a Franchise Like Gene Roddenberry
Просмотров 42 тыс.10 месяцев назад
How to Build a Franchise Like Gene Roddenberry
Dune (1984) Retrospective/Review - Dune Retrospective, Part 1
Просмотров 90 тыс.10 месяцев назад
Dune (1984) Retrospective/Review - Dune Retrospective, Part 1
Wing Commander IV: The Price of Freedom Retrospective/Review
Просмотров 16 тыс.11 месяцев назад
Wing Commander IV: The Price of Freedom Retrospective/Review
Independence Day (1996) Retrospective/Review
Просмотров 53 тыс.11 месяцев назад
Independence Day (1996) Retrospective/Review
Wing Commander III: Heart of the Tiger Retrospective/Review
Просмотров 23 тыс.11 месяцев назад
Wing Commander III: Heart of the Tiger Retrospective/Review
The Fifth Element (1997) Retrospective/Review
Просмотров 160 тыс.11 месяцев назад
The Fifth Element (1997) Retrospective/Review
The Plan | Caprica | Blood & Chrome - Battlestar Galactica Retrospective, Part 3
Просмотров 89 тыс.Год назад
The Plan | Caprica | Blood & Chrome - Battlestar Galactica Retrospective, Part 3
Why Writers DON'T Need a Plan - Battlestar Galactica | Babylon 5
Просмотров 41 тыс.Год назад
Why Writers DON'T Need a Plan - Battlestar Galactica | Babylon 5
Star Trek is actually based on a resource based economy created by the Venus Project. The one aspect of it usually not explained by Star Trek because it’s complicated is social engineering. The understanding that nurture influences nature, so showing positive reinforcement of certain behavior and negative reinforcement to others alters the way our brains and personality functions. so yes, we are predator species, but these traits desensitized or over incentivized depending on culture. Our baser instincts are always there, but the true nature of humans is that we are the most influenceable species on the Earth as well as the most sociable. As you can see the more I talk about the more complicated it gets hence the reason why Jean Ron Barry didn’t wanna explain it.
is the next video going to talk about Origins....i don't blame you if it doesn't
Best Start Trek film? Yes, but I think the best film ever made. This is a stand alone film even if you didn't know anything about it. The cast, the script, editing and score are outstanding. This will stay among my all-time favorites including The Wizard of Oz; it's just that iconic and on a grand scale. It is absolutely brilliant. The only thing it lacks, is an in-person meeting with Khan and Kirk in the same room at the same time. I overlook that because I have to, but it would have been nice to see another hand-to-hand combat between them.
I like that you placed Dr- Phlox and 'Zimmerman' at the top, though I would place Bashir a little higher on your list. Reason being is that like many nerds who became doctors, this was a character at the beginning of his journey of becoming a doctor. He choose to become one by performing 'frontier-medicine' (offending folks like Kira). He was always stumbling over himself as a doctor and scientist. Dealing with being this series awkward male character in Trek, as all series seems to have one or two, and yet somehow rising to the occasion. Bashir wasn't just a sometimes frustrated scientist/doctor, he had a frustrating personal life as well. Not only with love, but with professional and personal friendships also. He stuttered at times, because he was unsure of himself (with Dax asking her for a date), and could be the hero (with Odo treating the wounded), both sides were shown in the pilot 'Emissary'. He cured a generational plague in 'the Quickening'. And often debated curing alien cultures like in that episode and in 'Hypocratic Oath'. His character was the first to reshape Trek's view on 'augments', and delving into Trek's covert Section 31. And by way of the DS9 writers, Bashir's naive friendship gave us Garak, and his flair gave us holodeck creation Vic Fontaine. He gave us a view of someone straight out of the academy, and his journey towards a seasoned 7-year war veteran.
Be kind on part 5, Universe was by far my favourite Stargate series. Eeeeh, that's not true, I hated most of the characters - Eli in particular - but Rush was my favourite Stargate character EVER by FAR
I am a fan of Frank Herbert though, not a fan of Dune. I do prefer his Pandora series and while I wouldn't mind someone making a series (mini or not), I am worried about how they would butcher it as they have with Dune
Agree on every point. I still think Nemesis is a worse movie, but Insurrection is still pretty lousy.
TAS is a fun, whimsical addition to Trek.
Gene Roddenberry took pains to set the series on a firm foundation of real science, but some of the episodes have really bad science, such as The Alternative Factor. The hardness varies from one episode to another. Also, we can't know what unexpected discoveries will be made in the future. So the number of "miracle exemptions" is not necessarily a good measure of plausibility. Today, when we read The Black Star Passes, the description of a giant aircraft with 40 propellers on each wing sounds silly now that we have jet engines. To me, control panels on a starship seem implausible since by the time we develop a superluminal drive we should have the technology to control machinery by thought.
I'd describe Star Trek as sciencey soft science fiction. Or maybe sciencesque or something like that. It's got a lot of handwavey tech, but leans into the sciencing stuff out with it.
I remember coming home from school and putting on Stingray and Captain Scarlet. I saw UFO and Space: 1999 when they came out in the USA. Despite my annoyance at the really bad science, I enjoyed these shows and picked up the related paperback books. The first season of Space: 1999 was definitely better, with a more intelligent, philosophical tone. Maya was silly, and I was saddened by Bergman's absence. The aliens in Space: 1999 seemed much more truly alien than the aliens in other shows, but I don't know if that was the writing or just the European acting style. My favorite episodes were Breakaway, where the crew is trying to solve a scientific mystery, and War Games, with its interesting alien culture. UFO was interestingly bizarre and had some really good stories. I also liked the purple-haired moonbase girls. If only we'd had all that cool technology back in 1980!
Man. This show could have been so cool. The premise is amazing. But every character except for Janeway and the doctor was jarring to me
the brunnen G hair is so cool
A writer shouldn't make promises he can't keep. If you keep telling the viewers that the Cylons have a plan, then the Cylons damn well better have a plan that is eventually revealed. If the story is centered around finding Earth, then the show should conclude with the protagonist actually finding Earth, as promised. Having the end of the story turn out to be a massive cop-out is not good writing. So yes, you do need a plan so you have some idea where you're going.
Babylon 5 was done very well the first time, so there's nothing for a reboot to improve on. I want to see something new, not a pointless rehash of something I've already seen. I want a reboot of Crusade so I can see the rest of the story. That would also familiarize people with this universe. I have no problem with updating the CGI for the original Babylon 5 series, as was done with the original Star Trek series. Also, note that the second in command (originally Laurel Takashima) was originally intended to be a traitor.
So frustrating to me that Daniel Jackson never joined Atlantis.
JMS did his best to get the science right. He was aware that sound can't travel through a vacuum, so he tried just using music during space battles to reflect this reality.
Just when we were starting to get the bigger picture the show was abruptly canceled. I don't want a Babylon 5 reboot. That show was done very well already. I want a Crusade reboot so I can finally see the rest of the story and find out where JMS was going with it.
In regards to Odo. The Bajoran's left him in the position he was in during the occupation as the Constable. Naris gets along with him and goes to him for support regarding issues with the Federation. There are a few Bajorans that dislike him, most treat him with respect. He is never charged for any crime against the Bajorans even though the Bajorans are looking for revenge for the wrongs done to them during the occupation. It is apparent that Odo was so even handed and honorable in his position during the occupation that he was respected by all sides. While Odo comes off as cold and an agent of Law and Order, he does have a heart, he has a deep sense of right and wrong, and I suspect that he was tolerant of the Bajoran resistance as much as he could get away with. It is important that as a changeling he was not "personally" involved so to speak in the issues between the Bajorans and the Cardasians, he was more neutral. In being seen as neutral and fair he could do things that by taking a side he could not. It makes for a very interesting character and one that is more inline with the real world of there being few things that are black and white, but there are many shades of gray that must be navigated.
Love your vids though mate long time viewer
Could disagree more mate - briefing room scenes were awesome!
Would love a proper video from you on this show.. sooo underated
I love Voyager but I have the same problem with it as the Enterprise D, the Captain should be setting hi in the middle in a swivel chair so the captain can see everything going on at any time
Journey to Babel is Top 5. City on the edge is Top 3z what kind of list is this ???😂
I like Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan
Thumbnail: Pretty woman with big boobs in a tight top. Video: No pretty woman.
23:30 i think oneill would also havekilled the solders with the shield or killing his superior office while being fed. i dont think hes more ruthless
Damn, I just watched this Retrospective/Review and now have just spent over £114 buying the complete box set on Amazon - and I haven't watched a single episode....
cheers to the most unique, imaginative, bananas, smart & endearing scifi show that has ever existed! in our house friday nights belonged to farscape we never missed an episode! i will be forever grateful to farscape for coming into my life i will always love you farscape! thank you rowan ♡
I just finished all the shows again. I have never heard of this show. Did I switch timelines again?
I can't find the star wars bigotry fandom video you mentioned. Found the channel but not the video
Bummer, ... DS9 is by far the most watchable Star Trek in the 2020's
You did a brilliant job on these, I can't wait for the next part. I love Stargate. It was a big part of my childhood as my dad and me bonded over that and Star Trek. Keep up the great work!
In my opinion, SG1 should have ended with season 8, having one supporting season with the transition to Atlantis and then given SGA a 6th season to free Pegasus of the Wraith and ran that season in parallel with SGU's first season (which badly needed a supportive season considering the genre change).
Great series Rowan. I eagerly await your SGU video. I absolutely love it - it’s maybe my favourite series ever. I loved the music, effects, stories, characters and actors. Can’t wait to hear your views.
Wait. You like Discovery season 3 and 4? Most people think the early seasons were good and the show became a joke in later ones.